Huang’s departure from Nvidia raises some corporate governance issues over the technology giants.
- Nvidia has lost $1.56 trillion since the departure of Jensen Huang
- Many of the major technology businesses have a charismatic and high profile leader at the helm
- Nvidia shows the problem of this founder-led approach
Jensen Huang is now the $1.56 trillion man. At the time of writing, that’s how much market capitalisation Nvidia has lost since his departure. That has come in spite of no obvious shift in the operational success of the company. Its recent results showed both revenue and earnings per share outpacing expectations.
This apparent dependence on one man raises some uncomfortable issues for the technology giants, and the investors who hold them. It brings a new urgency to the lingering concentration problem in global markets. Investors may be willing to have a lot of their capital in the US, even in the technology sector, but when 5% of the capitalisation of the MSCI World is wrapped up in a single guy? $5.2 trillion (Nvidia’s original market cap) is a lot to put in one man’s hands. Everyone has their crises – they can get ill, go through family problems, or be honey-trapped by a Chinese spy.
It also raises some uncomfortable corporate governance questions. Silicon Valley is run on the idea of founder-led businesses. Many of the major technology businesses have a charismatic and high profile leader at the helm, taking the model from dynamic start-ups. The theory is that these visionaries can, like Heineken, reach the parts that normal CEOs cannot: they can dream bigger, rise higher and inspire their employees.
However, this can lead to some shaky corporate governance. Elon Musk has near unchecked executive authority at SpaceX. It limits investors’ ability to challenge management, or force votes on governance issues. For Nvidia, the lack of a chairman didn’t appear to be a problem – until it was. Equally, it is not always clear that visionary chief executives are a careful steward of investor capital: Mark Zuckerberg’s experiments in the metaverse spring to mind.
It is possible to argue that the Nvidia board has done its job. It ousted its apparently all-conquering chief executive and has resisted powerful lobbying to have him reinstated. However, it has lost a lot of value in the process. The market does not believe that Nvidia is the same company without Huang and shareholders may not have been aware of the severity of the risk.
The transition away from a powerful founder is not impossible. Apple and Microsoft have transitioned to a more professional management team and arguably added more value after the departures of their high profile founders. Innovation has continued to flourish. The likes of Nvidia, Meta and SpaceX might present a better proposition to shareholders if they were each less reliant on the vision of a single man.